Labs Unlisted preview
Fiscal Impact Studies, Side by Side
When a large housing project or a zoning change comes before a town, someone often writes a fiscal impact study. It estimates what the new homes will pay in taxes and what they’ll cost in schools, police, fire and other services.
I’ve gathered the studies I’ve been reading, from Arlington, Belmont and Braintree, and put their key numbers in one table. The table reports what each document says. Where I worked out a figure per home, I say so. It doesn’t judge which study is right. At the top are ten Arlington lots that have already been rebuilt, with what they paid in property tax before and what they pay now.
Tax revenue before and after: ten Arlington lots
Revenue only, no costs. Each lot was rebuilt since 2010. “Before” is the last assessment before the lot was sold or rebuilt; “after” is FY2026. Both are taxed at the FY2026 rate of $10.67 per $1,000, so the difference comes from the building, not from changes in the rate.
| Lot | Before | Value before | After | Value after (FY2026) | Tax before | Tax after | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arlington 360, Symmes Circle | Town-owned former Symmes Hospital site (FY2007) | $9,048,700, not taxed | Apartments, 2013 | $83,793,000 | $0 | $894,071 | +$894,071 |
| Brigham Square, 30–50 Mill St | Offices (FY2012) | $5,757,700 | Apartments and offices, 2012 | $60,596,000 | $61,435 | $646,559 | +$585,125 (11 times) |
| The Artemis, 1157–1165R Mass Ave | Office and warehouse (FY2023) | $3,388,300 | Apartments, 2023 | $50,822,100 | $36,153 | $542,272 | +$506,119 (15 times) |
| The Majestic, 1021–1025 Mass Ave | Three-family house, a house with an office (FY2024) | $3,489,300 | Apartments, 2025 | $13,541,700 | $37,231 | $144,490 | +$107,259 (3.9 times) |
| 93 Broadway | Auto repair (FY2017) | $890,200 | Day care, 2017 | $5,089,600 | $9,498 | $54,306 | +$44,808 (5.7 times) |
| 882–892 Mass Ave | Store and parking lot (FY2021) | $1,508,000 | Apartments, 2023 | $5,863,300 | $16,090 | $62,561 | +$46,471 (3.9 times) |
| 34 Dudley St | Auto repair (FY2024) | $1,167,700 | Storage warehouse, 2025 | $5,216,800 | $12,459 | $55,663 | +$43,204 (4.5 times) |
| 80 Broadway | Store (FY2023) | $946,400 | Shop with condos above, 2024 | $4,127,200 | $10,098 | $44,037 | +$33,939 (4.4 times) |
| 887–889 Mass Ave | Auto repair (FY2017) | $574,200 | Apartments with an office, 2018 | $3,040,600 | $6,127 | $32,443 | +$26,316 (5.3 times) |
| 483 Summer St | Auto repair (FY2015) | $355,700 | Apartments with an office, 2019 | $3,263,100 | $3,795 | $34,817 | +$31,022 (9.2 times) |
- Where these come from. Each lot’s assessment history in the assessor’s database (Previous Assessments tab), read November 6, 2026. I searched for buildings finished in 2015 or later and now assessed above $3 million, and kept the ones with a clear before and after. Left out: the Housing Corporation of Arlington’s 117 Broadway and 114 Lowell St (affordable housing, with values that jump between years).
- Lots that changed shape. The Majestic combines two lots (1021 and 1025 Mass Ave) and 882–892 Mass Ave took in the parking lot next door; “before” adds the old lots together. The Artemis lot lost about 11,000 sq ft along the way, so its “before” covers a slightly larger lot.
- Arlington 360 was on the tax rolls as vacant land from FY2008 to FY2012, once it left town ownership, at $7,462,200 ($79,622 a year at today’s rate). Brigham Square’s “after” includes its office space.
- The Majestic and 34 Dudley St were finished in 2025. Their FY2026 values may not show the whole building yet.
- Older “before” values, like Brigham Square’s from FY2012 or 483 Summer St’s from FY2015, would be higher today even with no new building, so the change for those lots is somewhat overstated.
- The Artemis study used a “before” value of $3,522,400 (FY2020) and forecast $47,060,000 after. The real FY2026 value came in 8% higher.
Large apartment buildings: homes and bedrooms
Homes and bedrooms for Arlington’s large apartment and condo buildings, to set beside counts of schoolchildren. Few buildings publish their mix by size, so some rows have only total bedrooms.
| Building | Built | Homes | Affordable | Studios | 1BR | 2BR | 3BR | Bedrooms in all | Bedrooms a home | Schoolchildren counted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arlington 360, Symmes Circle | 2013, rentals | 164 to 256; sources disagree | 35 | — | — | — | — | Studios to three bedrooms, including townhouses; no count by size found | — | 26 (Artemis study, 2020): 0.102 a home if 256 homes, 0.16 if 164 |
| Brigham Square, 30 Mill St | 2012, rentals | 116 | About 17 (15%) | 18 | 35 | 63 | 0 | 161 | 1.39 | 32 in 119 homes, 0.269 (Artemis study, 2020); 26 in 116, 0.22 (RKG, 2018) |
| The Artemis, 1165R Mass Ave | 2023, rentals | 124 | 31 | — | — | — | — | 178 | 1.44 | Not counted |
| The Artemis as proposed | Studied in 2020 | 130 | 33 | 31 | 55 | 31 | 13 | 156 | 1.20 | Forecast 26, 0.20 |
| 420–440 Mass Ave | 2000, rentals | 134 | — | — | — | — | — | 250 | 1.87 | Not counted |
| The Majestic, 1021–1025 Mass Ave | 2025, condos | 50 | 13 (five one-bedrooms and six two-bedrooms among them) | — | — | — | — | One to three bedrooms; no count by size found | — | Not counted |
| 882–892 Mass Ave | 2023, rentals | 22 | — | — | — | — | — | 21 | 0.95 | Not counted |
| Thorndike Place | Proposed, not built | 176 | 45 | 11 | 87 | 58 | 20 | 263 | 1.49 | Forecast 35, 0.20 |
| 126–128 Broadway | Approved April 6, 2026 | 28 | 6 | 0 | 20 | 8 | 0 | 36 | 1.29 | — |
| 259 Broadway | Approved March 2, 2026 | 14, all small | 2 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
Older apartment buildings
Every other Arlington apartment building assessed above $10 million, from the assessor’s record cards.
| Building | Built | Homes | Bedrooms in all | Bedrooms a home |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 127–133 Broadway | 1955 | 116 | 174 | 1.50 |
| 231–233 Mass Ave | 1948 | 81 | 101 | 1.25 |
| 180–186 Gardner St | 1967 | 79 | 75 | 0.95 |
| 276 Mass Ave | 1952 | 75 | 98 | 1.31 |
| 379–385 Mass Ave | 1971 | 70 | 84 | 1.20 |
| 19–27 North Union St | 1955–1958 | 62 | 62 | 1.00 |
| 1–6 Viking Ct | 1968 | 57 | 74 | 1.30 |
| 151 Mystic St | 1963 | 49 | 60 | 1.22 |
| 382–384 Mass Ave | 1958 | 44 | 51 | 1.16 |
- Where these come from. Brigham Square’s mix: New England Real Estate Journal, December 6, 2012. The Artemis: 124 homes and 31 affordable from its affordable housing listing, 178 bedrooms from the Zoning Board’s 2021 draft decision; the proposed mix is from its fiscal study. Thorndike Place: its fiscal study, Table One. The Broadway projects: Redevelopment Board hearing notes, 2026. The Majestic: its affordable lottery listing. Arlington 360: 35 affordable from its listing. The rest: the assessor’s record cards, read November 6, 2026.
- Arlington 360’s count. The Artemis study says 256 homes, the architect says 199, and Yardi Matrix and the assessor’s cards say 164 and 165. The cards list bedrooms for only one of its six buildings, so I left its bedrooms blank.
- Schoolchildren have been counted for only two buildings, both in the Artemis study’s Table Eleven and RKG’s slide 49. Counts for the others would have to come from the schools, by address.
- The Majestic’s record card shows six bedrooms for 50 homes, so it isn’t finished being assessed; I left its bedrooms blank.
The key measures
One column for each study. Per-home figures are the study’s totals divided by its number of homes. On a phone, scroll the table sideways.
| Measure | The Artemis, 1165R Mass AveArlington · Fougere · October 12, 2020 | Thorndike PlaceArlington · Fougere · January 8, 2021 | Industrial districts studyArlington · RKG · December 4, 2019 | Town fiscal model, FY2025Belmont · RKG, revised by staff · July–August 2025 | 10 Plain St, applicant’s studyBraintree · Fougere · August 11, 2025 | 10 Plain St, town’s peer reviewBraintree · Seidman · October 17, 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The study | ||||||
| Written for or submitted by | Submitted with the 40B application | Submitted with the 40B application | Town | Town | Submitted with the application | Town |
| What it covers | 130 rentals, 25% affordable | 176 rentals, 25% affordable | Typical new home of each type; figures here are for apartments | A model for any project or zoning change | 752 rentals | 752 rentals |
| Years modeled | One year | One year | One year | One year | One year | One year |
| Revenue | ||||||
| Assessed value per home | $362,000 | $360,000 | $408 a sq ft (new apartments built 2013 or later) | $440 a sq ft | $388,025 | $375,000–400,000 |
| Tax rate used, per $1,000 | $11.06 (FY2020) | $11.34 (FY2021) | Not stated | $11.39 (FY2025) | $9.98 (FY2025) | $9.98 (FY2025) |
| Property tax per home | $4,004 | $4,082 | $9,540 | Depends on the project | $3,872 | $3,517–3,770, after the site’s current taxes |
| Cars per home | 1.0 | 1.13 | Not stated | 0.3 | 1.14 | About 1.45 |
| Car excise per car | $500 ($20,000 car at $25 per $1,000) | $500 ($20,000 car at $25 per $1,000) | Not stated | $192, Belmont’s average bill | $250 ($10,000 car) | $214–250 (Braintree’s average car is $8,564) |
| Car excise per home | $500 | $563 | $200 | $58 | $285 | $310–362 |
| CPA surcharge in the revenue | Yes, $7,807 | Yes, $10,777 | Not stated | Not stated | Yes | Yes |
| Site’s current taxes subtracted | No (site assessed at $3,522,400) | No (vacant site pays $88,828 a year) | Not applicable | Not applicable | No ($195,499 a year) | Yes |
| Other revenue | None counted | None counted | $160 a home in fees, fines and permits | Hotel tax, for hotels | None counted | Meals tax, $9,323–18,646 |
| Schools | ||||||
| Schoolchildren per home | 0.20 (26 children) | 0.20 (35 children) | 0.19 | 0.30, all sizes; studios 0 | 0.156 (117 children) | 0.156 (117 children) |
| Where the child count comes from | Average of 14 40B rental complexes elsewhere in the region: 742 children in 3,765 homes. Two Arlington buildings are listed but not used | Same 14 complexes | Arlington’s apartments, 2018 | Seven Belmont buildings: 142 children in 469 homes | Two Braintree complexes, plus the consultant’s regional list for affordable and three-bedroom homes | Accepts the applicant’s count |
| Cost per added student | $10,463 | $10,463 | $7,297 | $13,756 | $5,368–10,736 (total ÷ 117) | $9,714–11,634 (total ÷ 117) |
| How the school cost is built | The schools’ formula, with 25% of fixed costs (administration, buildings) taken out, per the schools’ CFO | Same as the Artemis | Incremental cost per student from the Town Manager’s office | School budget lines judged variable (84%) plus their benefits, ÷ 4,538 pupils | Eight new teachers at $70,000, special education for 22% of students at $45,000, less state aid of $4,016 a student. Low case is half | Five to eight teachers at $74,852 with benefits, a $68,276 bus route, special education as the applicant, less state aid of $4,068 a student |
| School cost per year | $272,038 | $366,205 | $1,370 a home | Depends on the project | $628,056–1,256,112 | $1,136,580–1,361,136 |
| Other town costs | ||||||
| How police and fire are costed | Department budget ÷ calls, × expected calls | Department budget ÷ calls, × expected calls | Incremental share of each budget | Share of each budget judged incremental (police 49%, fire 81%) | Police: 2.5–3 officers for a new patrol sector. Fire: budget ÷ calls | Police: three officers, with benefits, and a cruiser. Fire: budget ÷ calls, plus 6% for the next contract |
| Police, fire and other town costs per home | $452 | $434 | $1,030 | $980 | $812–896 | $1,055 |
| Pensions and health insurance | No cost line | No cost line | $240 a home | Added by staff in 2025 to payroll lines and other costs | Teacher figure of $70,000; the peer review puts salary and benefits at $74,852 | In the teacher and police figures |
| Buildings, roads, water and sewer | Not counted | Not counted | Not counted | Not counted | Not counted; water and sewer connection fees counted as one-time revenue | Traffic, water and sewer “not yet fully analyzed” |
| Result | ||||||
| Net to the town each year | +$262,532 | +$385,610 | +$7,510 a home | Scenario results not in these files | +$1,225,571 to +$1,916,627 | +$732,942 to +$1,195,952 |
| Net per home each year | +$2,020 | +$2,191 | +$7,510 | — | +$1,630 to +$2,549 | +$975 to +$1,590 |
| Checked against the finished building | Built 2023. Assessed at $50,822,100 in the assessor’s database, 8% above the forecast. Children living there: not yet counted | Not built | No | No | Not built | Not built |
Schoolchildren per home, by size
Belmont’s staff collected the rates other towns’ studies have used. These are the rows with a clear rate for each size. Counts are schoolchildren per home.
| Town or method | Consultant | Market studio | Market 1BR | Market 2BR | Market 3BR | Affordable studio | Affordable 1BR | Affordable 2BR | Affordable 3BR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arlington | Fougere | 0.197 | 0.197 | 0.197 | 0.197 | 0.197 | 0.197 | 0.197 | 0.197 |
| Belmont | RKG | 0 | 0.30 | 0.30 | 0.30 | 0 | 0.30 | 0.30 | 0.30 |
| Belmont staff (from Newton and Newburyport) | Town staff | 0 | 0.163 | 0.214 | 0.800 | 0 | 0.163 | 1.018 | 1.190 |
| Braintree | Fougere | 0 | 0.001 | 0.115 | — | 0 | 0.02 | 0.57 | — |
| Newburyport | Fougere | 0 | 0.02 | 0.18 | 0.812 | 0 | 0.02 | 1.19 | 1.19 |
| Newton, method 1 | Newton | 0 | 0 | 0.214 | 0.8 | 0 | 0 | 1.018 | 2.792 |
| Newton, method 2 | Newton | 0.163 | 0.163 | 0.163 | 0.163 | 0.163 | 0.163 | 0.163 | 0.163 |
| Billerica | RKG | 0.12 for every size | |||||||
| Melrose | RKG | 0.095 for every size | |||||||
| Weston | RKG | 0.38 for every size | |||||||
Arlington’s own numbers
Figures to hold the studies up against.
| Measure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Spending per pupil, all sources | $20,549 (FY2024) | State Department of Elementary and Secondary Education |
| Health insurance and pensions | $45.78M, 19.4% of the general fund (FY2027 budget) | Town Manager’s FY2027 budget message |
| Tax rate | $10.67 per $1,000 (FY2026) | Board of Assessors |
| Car excise collected | $6.21M (FY2025) | Town of Arlington |
| New growth | 0.90% of the levy limit a year on average, FY2017–FY2026 | State Division of Local Services |
| Schoolchildren per home, Arlington 360 | 0.102 (26 in 256 homes) | Artemis study, Table Eleven |
| Schoolchildren per home, Brigham Square | 0.269 (32 in 119 homes) in the Artemis study; 0.22 (26 in 116) in RKG’s 2018 count | Artemis study, Table Eleven; RKG slide 49 |
| School enrollment | 5,208 in 2015 to 5,939 in 2019, up 14% | Artemis study, Table Ten |
The documents
Copies of everything the tables draw on.
- Arlington. Fiscal impact analysis, 1165R Massachusetts Avenue (the Artemis), Fougere Planning & Development, October 12, 2020 (PDF, 0.6 MB). Fiscal impact analysis, Thorndike Place, Fougere Planning & Development, January 8, 2021 (PDF, 0.4 MB). Economic analysis of industrial zoning districts, RKG Associates, December 4, 2019; the fiscal slides are 42–55 (PDF, 16 MB).
- Belmont. Updated RKG fiscal impact model, memo from the Director of Planning and the Finance Director, August 8, 2025 (PDF). The model itself, revised July 2025 (Excel). Schoolchildren rates by town (Excel). Belmont Center buildout method, August 14, 2025, and revised buildout figures, November 20, 2025 (PDF).
- Braintree. Peer review of the fiscal impact analysis for 10 Plain Street, Karl F. Seidman Consulting Services, October 17, 2025 (PDF, 0.9 MB).
Sources and limits
- The Braintree applicant’s figures come from the peer review’s Table 1 and its description of the study. I don’t have the applicant’s study itself, dated August 11, 2025.
- Belmont’s model is a spreadsheet, not a study of one project, so it has rates but no project totals. Staff planned 12 scenarios for Belmont Center; I don’t have their results.
- RKG’s 2019 figures are marked draft on the slides. They are for a typical new apartment, not a specific building.
- Per-home figures I worked out: property tax, cars, excise, cost per student, town costs and net per home, wherever a study gives only totals. Each is the total divided by the number of homes or children.
- Ranges are the study’s own low and high cases.
- “Not stated” means I didn’t find it in the document. It may be in a part I missed. Corrections are welcome at joeforarlington@gmail.com.
- Not included: the Majestic, 1021–1025 Mass Ave, a 40B project for which I found no fiscal study.